Is Cholula Good For You?

Health & Nutrition

Jul 31

IN THIS GUIDE: A health analysis of Cholula Original Hot Sauce (110mg sodium, xanthan gum-thickened), comparing it to 7 other popular brands (25mg–190mg range), explaining how ingredient choices affect sodium content and texture, and how fresh vegetable-based formulations achieve bold flavor at 25-50mg without processed thickeners.

That distinctive wooden cap and mild Mexican heat have made Cholula a kitchen staple worldwide. But is it actually good for your health? Here's the breakdown: zero calories and beneficial capsaicin, but 110mg sodium per teaspoon and processed ingredients like xanthan gum. Decent as an occasional choice—but healthier alternatives with bold flavor and dramatically lower sodium exist.

By Timothy Kavarnos, Founder | Salamander Sauce Company

Is Cholula Healthy? Quick Answer

Moderately healthy—Better than many commercial brands but not optimal
Zero calories and zero sugar—Good for weight management and diabetic-friendly
110mg sodium per teaspoon (5% daily value)—Higher than the healthiest hot sauces (25-50mg)
Contains capsaicin—Linked to metabolism boost and anti-inflammatory effects
Processed ingredients—Xanthan gum and vague "natural flavors"
Better alternatives available—Lower-sodium options deliver bold flavor without the tradeoffs

In This Post

Nutrition Facts
What's in the Bottle
EWG Analysis
Brand Comparison
Heat Level (Scoville)
Diet Compatibility
Healthier Alternatives
The Bottom Line
The Verdict
FAQ

Cholula has earned a devoted following with its balanced Mexican-style flavor and approachable heat. Made in Chapala, Mexico from a recipe passed down through three generations, this sauce with the distinctive wooden cap appears everywhere from diners to upscale restaurants.

But between the marketing about traditional recipes and the actual ingredient list, what's the real story? As someone who's formulated hot sauce for over 15 years in Brooklyn, I've analyzed dozens of commercial brands to understand how they stack up nutritionally. For a comprehensive breakdown of what makes hot sauce healthy or not, see our complete guide to the healthiest hot sauce options.

Cholula Nutrition Facts: The Numbers

Per 1 Teaspoon (5ml) Serving

Calories: 0
Total Fat: 0g
Sodium: 110mg (5% daily value)
Total Carbohydrates: 0g
Sugars: 0g
Protein: 0g
Heat Level: 1,000-2,000 Scoville units (mild to moderate)

Reality check: Most people use 2-3 teaspoons, multiplying sodium intake to 220-330mg per use.

Sugar Clarification

Cholula Original contains 0g sugar, but some varieties like Chipotle, Sweet Habanero, and Chili Lime DO contain added sugars according to ingredient lists, even when nutrition labels show 0g due to tiny serving sizes. Always check ingredient lists, not just nutrition facts. Learn more about reading hot sauce labels and identifying hidden ingredients.

What's Actually in the Bottle

Cholula Original ingredients: Water, Peppers (Arbol and Piquin), Salt, Acetic Acid, Xanthan Gum, Spices, Apple Cider Vinegar, Garlic Powder, and Natural Flavor.

Ingredient Breakdown

The Peppers: Arbol and Piquin

Chile de Arbol delivers 15,000-30,000 Scoville units with slightly smoky, nutty notes. Rich in capsaicin and vitamins A and C.

Piquin peppers offer moderate heat (40,000-60,000 SHU) with distinctive fruitiness and mild smokiness. These small, round peppers pack more capsaicin per gram than larger varieties.

The benefit: Both contain capsaicin, the compound linked to metabolism boost, pain relief, and anti-inflammatory effects. Learn more about hot sauce preservation techniques.

Salt: The Primary Concern

At 110mg per teaspoon, Cholula's sodium sits in the middle range for commercial brands—but significantly higher than the healthiest hot sauces, which deliver bold flavor at just 25-50mg per serving.

Sodium context:

American Heart Association recommends maximum 1,500mg daily
FDA maximum: 2,300mg daily for average adults
Cholula provides 5% of daily limit in one teaspoon
Heavy users consuming 2-3 teaspoons get 10-15% from this condiment alone
See our sodium comparison guide for a full breakdown

Processed Ingredients

Xanthan gum is produced from corn sugar fermented with bacteria. While FDA-approved, some people experience digestive upset or bloating. The corn source may be GMO. The cleanest hot sauces use fresh vegetables for body instead of processed thickeners.

"Natural Flavor" is a vague catch-all that could be problematic for people with allergies or sensitivities. Manufacturers aren't required to disclose exact components.

Is Hot Sauce Bad for Your Gut?

Vinegar is generally gut-neutral and can actually support digestive health in fermented forms like apple cider vinegar. The acetic acid in Cholula won't harm your gut.

Xanthan gum, however, can cause bloating, gas, or digestive discomfort in sensitive individuals. It's a corn-derived polysaccharide that some digestive systems struggle to process efficiently.

The alternative: Hot sauces thickened with fresh vegetables instead of synthetic gums use natural fiber that supports digestive health rather than potentially disrupting it. When I formulated Salamander, I used carrots and red bell peppers—the vegetable solids create body naturally without the potential for digestive upset.

Environmental Working Group (EWG) Analysis

Cholula's EWG Rating

According to EWG Food Scores, Cholula Original receives relatively positive marks with "low processing concerns."

EWG highlights:

Low processing concerns—Few artificial ingredients
Natural flavor flagged—Listed as "lower concern" but noted
Small serving size concern—Can make nutrition info misleading

Note: Different Cholula varieties receive different scores—flavors with added sugars score lower.

Cholula sits in the middle—not the worst, but significantly higher sodium than the healthiest alternatives that deliver bold, balanced flavor without processed thickeners.

How Cholula Compares to Other Brands

Hot Sauce	Sodium (mg)	Category	Key Notes
Salamander Whiskey	25mg	Very Low	Clean ingredients, bourbon complexity
Salamander Original	35mg	Very Low	Fresh vegetables, naturally thickened
Tabasco Original	35mg	Very Low	Three ingredients only
Salamander Tropical	50mg	Low	Fruit-forward, clean ingredients
Sriracha (Huy Fong)	75mg	Moderate	Contains sugar, preservatives
Cholula Original	110mg	Moderate	Xanthan gum, natural flavors
Frank's RedHot	190mg	High	Nearly double Cholula's sodium
Louisiana Original	240mg	Very High	Highest sodium among popular brands

With 25-50mg sodium compared to Cholula's 110mg, Salamander is one of the lowest sodium hot sauces available—using fresh vegetables for natural body and bold flavor instead of xanthan gum. For a side-by-side comparison of Cholula against lower-sodium options, see our guide to flavorful low-sodium alternatives to Cholula, Frank's, and Sriracha.

Cholula Heat Level: Scoville Rating Explained

Cholula Scoville Heat Units

Cholula Original rates 1,000-2,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU)—placing it in the mild-to-moderate range. This is milder than a jalapeño (2,500-8,000 SHU) but hotter than bell peppers (0 SHU).

Heat level comparison:

Tabasco Original: 2,500-5,000 SHU (hotter than Cholula)
Sriracha: 1,000-2,500 SHU (similar heat)
Salamander Original: 2,000-3,500 SHU (moderate heat with habanero)
Frank's RedHot: 450 SHU (much milder)

Why the mild heat? Cholula blends chile de arbol (15,000-30,000 SHU) with piquin peppers (40,000-60,000 SHU), but the water-diluted vinegar base significantly reduces overall heat concentration. The result is approachable spice without overwhelming burn—ideal for those new to hot sauce.

Lower Sodium Without Sacrificing Flavor

25-50mg sodium. Fresh vegetables for natural body. No xanthan gum.

Shop All Three Varieties

Not sure which? Original is where most people start.

Diet Compatibility Guide

One of the most common questions about Cholula: does it fit specific dietary patterns? Here's the breakdown:

Diet Type	Compatible?	Notes
DASH Diet	⚠️ Use with Caution	110mg per tsp adds up quickly; consider switching to 25-50mg options
Keto / Low-Carb	✅ Yes	0g carbs, 0g sugar—completely keto-friendly
Paleo	⚠️ Technically Yes	No grains/legumes, but strict adherents may avoid xanthan gum (corn-derived)
Vegan	✅ Yes	No animal products or derivatives
Gluten-Free	✅ Yes	No wheat, barley, rye, or gluten-containing ingredients
Whole30	⚠️ Maybe	Xanthan gum and "natural flavors" may violate strict interpretation

For strict clean-eating protocols, look for hot sauces with recognizable whole-food ingredients and no processed thickeners. Salamander uses fresh carrots, red bell peppers, and onions for body—ingredients that align with all major dietary patterns while delivering 25-50mg sodium.

Healthier Alternatives to Cholula

Lowest Sodium Options

Salamander Whiskey (25mg): Real bourbon deepens everything—tomato, peppers, golden raisins, and hickory smoke transform into bourbon vanilla and caramel sweetness. Deep, dark, inviting.
Salamander Original (35mg): Jalapeño sparks the fire, habanero takes it deeper—heat that greets you fast and lingers slow. The sauce that started the revolution.
Tabasco Original (35mg): Simple three-ingredient formula—clean but limited flavor complexity

Cleanest Ingredients

Salamander sauces: No artificial thickeners—we use fresh vegetables for body and natural sweetness. See all ingredients and nutrition facts.
Small-batch artisanal brands: Focus on whole food ingredients over processing shortcuts
Single-ingredient sauces: Pepper-and-vinegar only formulations—minimal but one-dimensional

Similar Heat Level

Tabasco Chipotle: Smoky Mexican flavor, simple ingredients, lower sodium
Yellowbird Sriracha: Organic ingredients, no preservatives
Secret Aardvark: Pacific Northwest craft sauce with clean ingredients

The Salamander Standard: Why I Rejected Xanthan Gum

When I formulated Salamander in Brooklyn over fifteen years ago, I made a specific choice to avoid xanthan gum and other thickeners. Working in New York restaurants—front of house and kitchen—I learned that texture matters as much as flavor.

I realized that if I used fresh carrots and red bell peppers instead of just water and vinegar, the sauce would thicken naturally through vegetable fiber. It creates a texture that sits on the food rather than sliding off, without the slimy mouthfeel that gums can sometimes create.

This approach brings the sodium down naturally (25-50mg vs 110mg) because I'm not using salt to mask the flavor of processed ingredients. The vegetables provide natural glutamates—the same savory compounds that make salt taste good—so the sauce delivers bold, balanced flavor without requiring high sodium.

Fresh vegetables, real bourbon in the Whiskey variety, whole fruits in the Tropical. Same formulations for over fifteen years. Made in New York's Hudson Valley. 8oz bottles—60% larger than the industry standard 5oz. Learn more about why we make it differently →

The Bottom Line

When you look at what makes hot sauce healthy—low sodium, clean ingredients, beneficial capsaicin without the processing shortcuts—the picture becomes clear.

Cholula delivers 110mg sodium per teaspoon through xanthan gum and natural flavors. The healthiest hot sauces deliver bold flavor at 25-50mg through fresh vegetables and real ingredients. That's not a slight difference—it's 55-77% less sodium while gaining nutritional value from whole foods instead of processed thickeners.

The evidence is straightforward: Salamander is one of the healthiest hot sauces with 25-50mg sodium, zero artificial ingredients, and fresh vegetables creating natural body and bold, balanced flavor. Not as a compromise. As the whole point.

This is what healthy hot sauce looks like when you refuse shortcuts.

The Salamander Standard

When we set out to make a better hot sauce, we refused to compromise. Here's what we measure ourselves against—and what every bottle delivers:

✓ Flavor and fire working together to elevate your food
✓ Fresh vegetables first, not vinegar and water
✓ 10+ flavor ingredients in every bottle—see the full list
✓ Small-batch crafted in New York's Hudson Valley
✓ 50mg or less sodium per serving
✓ No xanthan gum or artificial thickeners

Ready to taste the difference? Original is where most people start.

The Verdict

Cholula falls into the "moderately healthy" category among commercial hot sauces, but it's not optimal if you prioritize clean ingredients and minimal sodium.

✅ Positives

Zero calories support weight management
Beneficial capsaicin from authentic peppers
No saturated fats or sugars
Moderate sodium vs highest-sodium brands
EWG rates low processing concerns
Traditional Mexican recipe

❌ Concerns

Higher sodium (110mg) than the healthiest hot sauces (25-50mg)
Processed ingredients like xanthan gum instead of fresh vegetables
Vague "natural flavor" lacks transparency
Limited nutritional value
Potential digestive issues from additives
Small serving size misleading for actual usage

Final assessment: If you enjoy Cholula's taste and use it sparingly, it can fit in a balanced diet. But if you're optimizing for health and using hot sauce daily, switching to one of the lowest sodium hot sauces with clean ingredients makes a meaningful difference. The cumulative impact over weeks and months—both in sodium reduction and whole food nutrition—supports long-term cardiovascular health without sacrificing the bold flavor that makes hot sauce worthwhile.

Tips for Healthier Use

Portion Control

Stick closer to the 1 teaspoon serving rather than liberally dousing food. Most people use 2-3x the listed amount, multiplying sodium to 220-330mg per use.

Balance Daily Sodium

If you use Cholula regularly, reduce sodium elsewhere to compensate. Choose low-sodium versions of other condiments and foods.

Switch to Lower Sodium

If you're using Cholula daily, consider switching to one of the lowest sodium hot sauces (25-50mg) instead of 110mg. The cumulative difference over weeks and months is significant for cardiovascular health. Your taste buds adjust within 2-3 weeks, and you'll start noticing more complexity in sauces built on fresh vegetables and bold flavor rather than salt.

Read Labels

Stick to Cholula Original if health is a priority—avoid varieties with added sugars like Chipotle and Sweet Habanero.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cholula hot sauce healthy?

Cholula is moderately healthy with zero calories and beneficial capsaicin, but contains 110mg sodium and processed ingredients like xanthan gum. The healthiest hot sauces contain 25-50mg sodium with cleaner ingredients—delivering bold, balanced flavor without the tradeoffs.

How much sodium is in Cholula?

110mg per teaspoon (5% daily value). Compare to Salamander Whiskey (25mg), Salamander Original (35mg), and Salamander Tropical (50mg), Tabasco (35mg), and Frank's RedHot (190mg). See our sodium comparison guide for the complete breakdown.

Does Cholula contain sugar?

Cholula Original contains 0g sugar. However, varieties like Chipotle, Sweet Habanero, and Chili Lime DO contain added sugars despite showing 0g on nutrition labels due to small serving sizes. Always check ingredient lists.

Is Cholula healthier than Tabasco?

Tabasco is healthier with only 35mg sodium (versus 110mg) and simpler ingredients—just peppers, vinegar, and salt without xanthan gum or natural flavors. Both are decent options, but the lowest sodium hot sauces at 25-50mg offer even better health profiles with fresh vegetables and bold flavor complexity.

Can I eat Cholula every day?

Yes, in moderation. The 110mg sodium adds up quickly with daily use, so monitor total daily intake, especially if you have high blood pressure or cardiovascular concerns. For daily use without guilt, consider switching to one of the lowest sodium hot sauces (25-50mg) that let you enjoy hot sauce at every meal without exceeding healthy sodium limits.

What's a healthier alternative to Cholula?

Salamander is one of the healthiest hot sauces with dramatically lower sodium (25-50mg vs. Cholula's 110mg) and zero artificial thickeners. Salamander Original (35mg) delivers bold, balanced flavor through fresh vegetables and habaneros, while Salamander Whiskey (25mg) adds bourbon complexity—both without compromising on the flavor that makes hot sauce worth using. Tabasco Original (35mg) is another solid choice with simple ingredients.

What are the healthiest hot sauce brands?

Look for 25-50mg sodium, no artificial thickeners, whole food ingredients, and balanced heat. Salamander is one of the cleanest hot sauce brands with 25-50mg sodium, zero xanthan gum, and fresh vegetables creating natural body and bold flavor. Other quality options include Tabasco Original (35mg, simple ingredients) and small-batch craft brands that prioritize whole foods over processing shortcuts. See our complete healthiest hot sauce guide for detailed comparisons.

How many Scoville units is Cholula?

Cholula Original rates 1,000-2,000 Scoville Heat Units—placing it in the mild-to-moderate range. This is milder than a jalapeño (2,500-8,000 SHU) but hotter than Sriracha (1,000-2,500 SHU). The approachable heat makes it ideal for those new to hot sauce or building spice tolerance.

Is Cholula keto-friendly?

Yes, Cholula Original is completely keto-friendly with 0g carbs and 0g sugar per serving. It fits all low-carb eating patterns without breaking ketosis.

Final Recommendation

Cholula is fine as an occasional choice, but if you're using hot sauce regularly, investing in one of the lowest sodium hot sauces with cleaner ingredients will serve your long-term health better. The small price difference between mass-market and craft hot sauces is worth it for the significant improvements in sodium reduction and ingredient quality—especially when you get bold, complex flavor instead of making compromises.

📚 Related Reading

Over 15 Years of Making It the Same Way

25-50mg sodium. Fresh vegetables. Real bourbon. Zero additives.

Free shipping on 3+ bottles. Arrives damaged? We replace it, no questions.

Try the Three-Pack